If your first impression of a typical control system schematic drawing is
complete confusion, don't worry: you're not alone. All of those strange
symbols really stand for something you should know, right? Throw in a PLC,
and the confusion grows. However, if you approach these drawings with a
solid understanding of the basics, the mystery fades away.
Do you approach a set of control system drawings as an archeologist trying
to decipher hieroglyphics? Sure, some systems can be quite complex. But you
can transform this tedious task from decryption to analyzation. All you
need is practical knowledge of control symbols, what they denote, and how
various control components work. It's not that difficult.
Decrypting the symbols.
As this author discovered early in his career, drawings for industrial
control systems use a unique set of symbols. Although some are similar to
those used in other electrical drawings, you'll find many only in the
industrial control area. Control systems use many different types of switches and contacts used as
input devices; Fig. 1 (original article) shows some of the more common
ones. A human operator actuates these switches. Notice how you can draw each of these devices in either the normally open
or normally closed configuration. This is true of many control symbols.
Normally open devices are open (not conducting) when you don't actuate them
and closed (conducting) when you do actuate them. On the other hand,
normally closed devices remain closed when you don't actuate them and open
when you do actuate them. The toggle switches shown in Fig. 1 (original article) may or may not
return to the "normal" position after you actuate them. Therefore, all
control system drawings should specify if a toggle switch maintains its
last position, or if it has a spring to return it to the normal position.
The other devices shown in Fig. 1 (original article) typically return to
the normal position when not actuated. Fig. 2 (original article ) shows switches actuated by a process, product,
or machine (rather than a human operator). Note: We show limit switches in
both their normal (not actuated) positions and "held" positions. This is
because some designers chose to show limit switches in their true normal
state, which can be either normally open-held closed or normally
closed-held open. Suppose you use a limit switch as a safety interlock on a
cabinet door. Here, it might be a normally open switch held closed by the
door when the machine is in normal operation.
The other switches shown in Fig. 2 (original article) detect a change in
some value of a process. With these types of devices, the normally
open/normally closed distinction can sometimes be confusing. No matter
what's normal for the process, the measured value actuates these switches
when it rises. For example, a normally open liquid level switch closes on
rising level and opens on falling level. A normally closed pressure switch,
on the other hand, opens on rising pressure and closes on falling pressure.
If it better reflects normal operating conditions, you can draw these
devices in their "held" position. One more thing to watch out for: Many often draw switches that measure
vacuum as pressure switches, but vacuum is actually negative pressure.
Here, you must be careful in determining the proper behavior of the switch.
Does a normally open device close on rising vacuum or on rising pressure,
which is actually falling vacuum? See what we mean? You're going to have to
test these devices if you're not sure of their function (as noted on the
drawings). You may run into drawings that include notes such as "switch
closes at 15 in. Hg vacuum" to eliminate confusion. Fig. 3 (original article) shows devices actuated by other devices in the
circuit. For example, a relay coil, when energized, will actuate its
contacts. Normally open contacts will close and normally closed contacts
will open. When not energized, the contacts are in their normal positions. Take timer contacts as another example. Special relays that perform a
timing function actuate them. When you energize a timer contact, an
on-delay timer begins timing immediately and actuates its associated
contacts after the preset time expires. When you de-energize it, the
timer's contacts return to their normal positions immediately with no
delay. Most drawings designate on-delay timer contacts as normally
open-timed close (NOTC) or normally closed-timed open (NCTO). An off-delay timer has the opposite behavior: Its contacts change state
immediately when you energize the timer but remain in the actuated state
when you de-energize the timer until the preset time expires. Most drawings
designate off-delay timer contacts as normally open-timed open (NOTO) or
normally closed-timed closed (NCTC). Fig. 4 (original article) shows many other symbols commonly found in
control diagrams. The motor shown is the common 3-phase squirrel cage type,
but you'll see different symbols for other motor varieties like wound rotor
and synchronous motors. Almost all control drawings use the coil symbol, and you may see it labeled
to further identify its purpose. Designers use this symbol for control
relays (CR), motor contactors (M or MC), and timers (TR), among other
devices. The lamp symbol often contains a letter to designate color, such as the
letter "R" for red. Designers use the magnetic coil or solenoid symbol to denote devices like
solenoid-operated valves, electric clutch or brake coils, and magnetically
operated circuit breaker coils. (Some additional notation usually clarifies
this.) Shown are values or ratings for resistors, capacitors, inductors,
fuses, and circuit breakers. Of course, we all associate the thermal element symbol with thermal
overload trip devices, which are used for motor protection. The transformer shown is a single-phase control transformer; you'll usually
find the size and input/output voltage ratio noted on the drawing. We use the very familiar earth ground symbol to represent grounds actually
referenced to an earth-contact ground rod or grid in a power distribution
system. The chassis ground symbol basically represents a connection to a common
chassis that's not earth grounded, such as the electrical system in a
vehicle or airplane. The connector symbol can represent any type of plug-in
connection.
Decrypting PLC inputs.
So now you have an understanding of symbols and their meaning. But what
about that intimidating looking black box called a PLC? Interpreting the
state of inputs to PLCs can be particularly confusing. Why? Because you can
program a normally open or normally closed input device as either an
examine-on (normally open contact) or examine-off (normally closed contact)
instruction in the PLC. So what's "examining" what? A PLC interprets an examine-on instruction as conducting if its associated
input circuit is energized. It interprets an examine-off instruction as
conducting if its associated input circuit is de-energized. Whether or not
an input is electrically energized depends on the state of the process and
type of connected device. The table (original article) shows all possible combinations of devices
(normally open or normally closed), actuation, and program instructions
(examine-on or examine-off), and how the PLC program interprets each
combination. Why are there two types of diagrams? You'll run into two types of diagrams
that describe electrical control systems: the schematic (sometimes called
elementary) diagram and the wiring (sometimes called connection) diagram.
Even moderately complex systems use them.
Schematic diagram.
This diagram describes the electrical function of a circuit or system. Fig.
5 (original article) shows a schematic diagram for a 3-phase motor starter.
Designers use this type of diagram to make following current or logic flow
easy. As you can see, they lay out these various devices for convenience
and clarity. Their locations in the drawing don't represent their actual
physical locations. For example, the coil, motor starter contacts, and auxiliary contact (all
labeled "M") are physically parts of the same device, but we show them in
three different locations to simplify the drawing.
Wiring diagram. Fig. 6 (original article) shows a wiring diagram for the
same motor starter. Here, we see the approximate physical locations of the
various components as well as the actual physical wiring connections
between them. Note that you now group the motor starter coil and contacts
together in the approximate physical relationship you would see in the
actual starter. The wiring diagram also clearly shows how the wiring routes
between the devices and how you make the interconnections. For example, it's obvious the start and stop buttons and red light are
actually located in a remote pushbutton station. It's also obvious a
four-conductor cable containing wire numbers 1A, 2, 3, and 4A connects that
station to the motor starter, which is located in a motor control center. As you can see, it's easier to make an estimate of material and labor from
a wiring diagram than from a schematic diagram. In the latter, you can't
tell if the pushbutton station and pilot light are together, separate,
remote, or part of the starter. Troubleshooting requires both types of drawings. If you're troubleshooting
a control system, make sure you use both the schematic and wiring diagram
(if they're available). You can use the schematic diagram to follow the
sequence of events and the wiring diagram to see where you make your
measurements. Let's suppose you're troubleshooting the motor circuit shown in Figs. 5 and
6 (original article). The motor won't start when you push the start button.
Looking at the schematic drawing (Fig. 5), you decide the start button will
not work unless there is power on Wire 2. The wiring diagram (Fig. 6) shows
you can find Wire 2 on the top side of the motor auxiliary contact in the
MCC or out in the remote pushbutton station. A check indicates there's no
power at the auxiliary contact, so you look at the schematic diagram again.
It shows power flows through the stop button from Wire 1A, and the wiring
diagram shows the stop button in the remote station. You go to the remote
station and find Wire 1A is broke at the stop button. You make the repair
and return the motor to service. As you can see, this troubleshooting process is much more straightforward
using both drawings than working with either one or the other alone. It's necessary to have a thorough understanding of the symbols, notations,
and conventions used on these drawings to read them properly. A good
understanding of such symbols ensures you interpret logic correctly, and
the effective use of schematic and wiring diagrams will make
troubleshooting control systems easier and faster.
|